Jingle Bells! Mrs. Peabody’s 2020 Christmas crime recommendations

Well, it’s been quite a year. My ‘crime time’ has been severely dented by all the upheaval, but here are some of my reading and viewing gems.

Treat others! Treat yourself!

And if you’re in the UK, please consider using https://uk.bookshop.org/, which is a brilliant way to support local booksellers while keeping yourself and others safe.

Mrs. Peabody’s 2020 Christmas crime recommendations!

Knives Out, directed by Rian Johnson, 2019 (USA)

Wealthy mystery novelist Harlan Thrombey celebrates his 85th birthday at his mansion surrounded by his loving family. The next morning he is found dead; his throat has been cut. Enter the police and investigator Benoit Blanc, who begin to discover clues…and some unsavoury secrets within the family.

My son recommended this film to me with the words ‘you’ll love this’ and he was absolutely right. Knives Out is huge fun from start to finish, as well as a razor sharp commentary on race and class in the USA. Cuban-Spanish actress Ana de Armas is fantastic as Marta Cabrera, Harlan’s beleaguered carer, who finds herself placed in a very tricky situation. And the all-star cast — including Daniel Craig, Chris Evans, Jamie Lee Curtis, Toni Collette, Don Johnson and Christopher Plummer — have a high old time hamming their way through this clever take on the Golden Age country house mystery. Perfect Christmas viewing for those who like their crime martinis both shaken and stirred.

Hannelore Cayre, The Godmother, tr. Samantha Smee, Pushkin Press 2019 (France)

Opening line: My parents were crooks, with a visceral love of money.

This prize-winning novel was recommended to me by crime writer Angela Savage a while ago, and it’s a cracker. As a translator myself, I was hugely tickled by the idea of a police interpreter inadvertently falling into a life of crime. And Madame Patience Portefeux, a 53-year-old widow with some tough times behind her, relates her story with wit, verve and plenty of caustic insight into French society. There’s an excellent review of the novel by RoughJustice over at Crime Fiction Lover (minor spoilers) – a very entertaining festive read! Winner of the 2020 CWA Crime Fiction in Translation Dagger.

Shirley Jackson, We Have Always Lived in the Castle, Penguin 2009 [1962] (USA)

Opening line: My name is Mary Katherine Blackwood.

This cult Gothic (crime) novel was one of those ‘how-have-I-never-read-this-before’ books. Mary Katherine — or Merricat — lives a largely isolated life in the Blackwood home with her sister Constance and Uncle Julian. Early on, she nonchalantly tells us that ‘everyone else in my family is dead’. The rest of the novel teases out the unfortunate story of the deceased Blackwoods, and relates a series of events in the present that will have a decisive impact on the family’s future.

I was instantly hooked by Merricat’s highly original voice and the novel’s creepy Gothic atmosphere. It also has some interesting things to say about suffocating patriarchy, sisterly sacrifice and social exclusion. We Have Always Lived in the Castle is a genuinely unsettling delight and I’m sure I’ll be rereading it a number of times.

Antti Tuomainen, Little Siberia, tr. David Hackston, Orenda Books (Finland)

Opening line: ‘And how do you know what happens then?’

Our 2020 Petrona Award winner, by one of crime fiction’s most inventive and versatile writers – what’s not to like?!

Little Siberia, set in an icy northern Finland, opens with a bang when a meteorite unexpectedly lands on a speeding car. Transferred to the local museum for safe keeping, the valuable object is guarded from thieves by local priest Joel, who is grappling with both a marital crisis and a crisis of faith. Absurdist black humour is expertly combined with a warm, perceptive exploration of what it means to be human. A celebration of resilience, fortitude and simply muddling through, this is a novel for our times.

Giri/Haji, BBC 2020 (Japan/UK; now on Netflix)

Giri/Haji [Duty/Shame] is billed as a ‘soulful thriller set in Tokyo and London, exploring the butterfly effect of a single murder across two cities — a dark, witty, and daring examination of morality and redemption’. And that’s pretty much spot on.

I was addicted from the first episode, which sees frazzled Japanese police detective Kenzo Mori (Takehiro Hira) sent to London to find his wayward brother and stop a Yakuza war. The characterization of the main players is fantastic – including Kelly MacDonald as Detective Sarah Weitzmann and Will Sharpe as Rodney, a rent boy whose dad is from Kyoto and whose mum is from Peckham… There’s also some beautifully inventive use of film techniques and genres, including a number of sequences that draw on manga. I can’t find this on DVD, and it’s gone from iPlayer, but it *is* on UK Netflix. Sneak off from Christmas duties, pour yourself a glass of sherry, and get stuck in.

And finally… Ragnar Jonasson’s ‘Hulda’ or ‘Hidden Iceland’ trilogy (Penguin), which is told in reverse, with each novel set prior to the last (when Hulda is aged 64, 50 and 40).

The first novel, The Darkness (tr. Victoria Cribb) introduces us to taciturn Reykjavik Detective Inspector Hulda Hermannsdóttir. She’s about to be shoved into retirement, but is grudgingly offered the chance to look into one last cold case before she goes – that of Elena, a young Russian woman whose body was found on the Icelandic coast. This is an intriguing, multilayered novel, whose true power only becomes evident right at the end. Jónasson dares to follow through in a way that few crime writers do, and the final result is very thought-provoking indeed. The second in the series is just as powerful, and I’m looking forward to reading the third. I have a theory about how things will go. Let’s see if I’m right!

Happy reading, stay safe, and wishing you all a wonderful and very merry Christmas!

13 thoughts on “Jingle Bells! Mrs. Peabody’s 2020 Christmas crime recommendations

  1. Some excellent recommendations here, Mrs. P.! I thoroughly enjoyed Knives Out, and I’m so glad you did, too. Brilliant dialogue, and I think you’re right about the commentary. Solid mystery, too, and plenty of wit. And We Have Always Lived… is, in my opinion, one of Jackson’s best works. It’s quite chilling…

    • Thanks, Margot! I’ve promised myself another viewing of KNIVES OUT before Christmas — and plan to seek out some more of Jackson’s work. Happy holidays ! xxx

  2. I am always delighted when someone new discovers Shirley Jackson – she is just one of my favourite writers, such a unique voice, which modulates itself so well to suit every situation. And horror creeps in on soft slippers…

  3. Knives Out and Giri/Haji are absolutely brilliant. The latter, in particular, is one of the best series I’ve seen on television, ever. Just fabulous stuff.

    Once again, you’re likely to cost me money, as I don’t know that I can resist a series about a taciturn Icelandic detective named Hulda Hermannsdóttir. Sounds like something that should be turned into a series — with subtitles! Jackson’s works are on my list already, of course, but may have to wait until I get through more bleak northern stories….

    • I totally agree with you about GIRI/HAJI. It was my top TV drama of the year, crime or otherwise. Every episode was just perfection.

      Hope you enjoy the Hulda trilogy! 🙂

  4. This is a wonderful list of suggestions. I have the Shirley Jackson book and keep putting it off because I don’t like creepy. But I think I will like it when I give into reading it. You have reminded me to rewatch Knives Out. All of the books sound good and some of them are new to me.

    • Thanks, Tracy – I do hope you like CASTLE once you get into it. It’s probably fairly mild in terms of creepiness compared to more recent stuff, but then again, acceptable levels of creepiness are a personal thing! KNIVES OUT pulls off something rare, I think – it’s incredibly entertaining, but there’s a serious message under the surface. I really hope the actors had as much fun as I think they did. It looked to me like they had a ball, especially Jamie Lee Curtis 🙂

  5. Hi Kat,

    Lots to wish for in your latest post but icing on cake for me is that the whole of Spiral is going on to the BBC i-Player! I came to it late and never really caught up so ‘I won’t care if it hails or freezes and I don’t need a plastic Jesus…’

    Compliments of the season to you and yours Maura x

    On Sat, 12 Dec 2020 at 14:09, Mrs. Peabody Investigates wrote:

    > Mrs P. posted: ” Well, it’s been quite a year. My ‘crime time’ has been > severely dented by all the upheaval, but here are some of my reading and > viewing gems. Treat others! Treat yourself! And if you’re in the UK, please > consider using https://uk.bookshop.org/, which ” >

  6. Delighted that you enjoyed The Godmother, Mrs P. Our whole family enjoyed ‘Knives Out’. And I also read Shirley Jackson this year. Here’s wishing you and yours a happy and healthy festive season filled with choice reading and viewing.

    • All proper crackers! Wishing you and yours a happy and healthy festive season, too! Ours is going to be a small gathering this year, so plenty of reading and viewing lined up 🙂

Please leave your comment here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.