A hard rain’s a-gonna fall… Reading as empowerment & solace

This isn’t a normal kind of post, because this isn’t a normal kind of day.

The inauguration of the new U.S. president will affect everyone to some degree in the coming months and years. Understandably, it’s making many of us feel extremely anxious, either because we live in America, because we have family and friends in America, or because we know our history and see right-wing forces on the rise around the world. Seeing those billionaire tech bros scrambling to get on board, positively encouraging the spread of disinformation, isn’t helping either. It all feels quite grim.

So here’s a small contribution: a two-part reading list whose aim is to empower or provide solace — whatever your need. In troubled times, books can be a lifeline.

EMPOWERMENT

There’s a reason why certain novels get banned by repressive regimes. Words and stories are powerful. They give us knowledge, courage and hope. They show us that other futures are possible. They provide us with a moral compass. They illuminate the methods repressive regimes use to control others. They give us concrete strategies for navigating tough times. They are survival manuals. They facilitate resistance.

Many also explore the theme of criminality, because when repressive regimes take power, they tend to redefine notions of crime. Things that are accepted by a true democracy — such as being a member of an opposition party or organization, working as a union official, voicing criticism of the government, identifying as LGBTI, belonging a particular ethnicity or religion, or (for women) simply choosing what clothes to wear — can quickly become criminalized. Once that happens, the state can start punishing citizens in the courts for ‘crimes’ ranging from ‘treason’ to ‘undermining state order’ to being ‘immodestly dressed’. And because the state is weaponizing the law to enforce its own power rather than upholding the law in good faith, the state itself becomes criminal. It commits crimes against the people it is supposed to serve.

Margaret Atwood, The Testaments (Penguin 2019) and The Handmaid’s Tale (Vintage 2017 [1985])

Where else to start than Margaret Atwood’s iconic dystopian novels about the theocratic Republic of Gilead, formerly the United States, which draw on elements from repressive regimes throughout history. These novels show how quickly a democracy can fall and be replaced by a totalitarian regime; how individuals are given terrible choices to co-opt them into policing others on the regime’s behalf; how things as universal as reading or loving can swiftly become criminalized; how acts of resistance are always possible, but require incredible courage and determination; and how even the most repressive of regimes can fall. The TV adaptation with Elisabeth Moss is stunning. Note: The Handmaid’s Tale is one of the most frequently banned books in America.

Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall Trilogy (Fourth Estate 2009, 2012, 2020)

Hilary Mantel’s extraordinary novels explore the rise and fall of Thomas Cromwell (1485-1540), fixer extraordinaire to King Henry VIII. We’re given an intimate view of what it’s like to spend years in the inner circle of a mercurial, murderous, absolute monarch, and the impossibility of remaining untouched by the crimes you commit in his name. A cautionary tale that demonstrates how serving morally bankrupt people tends to come at a high price. They will dump you the minute you outlast your usefulness.

C. J. Sansom’s absorbing ‘Shardlake’ crime series is set in the same historical period, and sees London lawyer Matthew Shardlake cross paths with Cromwell in the first two books, Dissolution and Dark Fire. The Tudor period was a truly terrifying time to live, not least because of the brutality of its criminal justice system.

Sarah Gailey, Upright Women Wanted (tor.com 2020)

From the past to the future: Sarah Gailey’s Upright Women Wanted takes place in an American Southwest that’s a few years into a totalitarian regime. Young Esther stows away in a travelling Librarians’ book wagon to escape marriage to a man once betrothed to Beatriz, her best friend. Beatriz also happens to have been her secret lover and has just been executed for possessing resistance materials. This is a hard-hitting but hopeful tale of courage and resistance, which features some truly impressive and subversive librarians. As we all know, librarians rock.

Paul Lynch, Prophet Song (Oneworld 2023) 

In this speculative novel, which won the 2023 Booker Prize, Ireland has recently been taken over by a totalitarian regime. At the start of the book, Larry Stack, a trade unionist and deputy head teacher, is disappeared by the secret police while attending a protest rally: his professional activities and actions are now deemed criminal by the state. His wife Eilish is left to hold the family together in increasingly fraught circumstances. The lesson here is how quickly things can unravel and how costly hesitation can be. Eilish is in shock and torn by conflicting needs — to help her husband, to care for her kids and elderly dad — but staying on rather than getting some of the family out while she has the chance may prove a mistake. Always be prepared; always have a plan.

KAOS, Netflix 2024

A wild reimagining of Greek mythology, whose stellar cast includes Jeff Goldblum, KAOS has a lot to teach us about how repressive regimes tick. The gods rule the world with an iron hand from Mount Olympus, not just because they’re powerful, but because they’ve duped humans into believing that obedience will secure them a glorious afterlife. But what if that deal is an elaborate swindle? A ragtag band of individuals, including recently deceased Riddy (Eurydice), are about to find out. Once again, resistance is shown to require huge amounts of courage and sacrifice. On the flip side: no power is monolithic, any regime can be toppled, every charlatan is unmasked in the end.

SOLACE

British commentator Ian Dunt has some wise words about retaining our sanity over the next four years:

You can adopt a system of largely ignoring the chaff and focusing on the pertinent actions. You can make sure that you have time away from the news, so it does not consume you. You can focus your efforts on what you can change, rather than what you cannot.

I think this is really good advice. Don’t ‘live inside the news’, as Oliver Burkeman puts it, do set aside time to enjoy reading or knitting or hiking or playing the banjo or whatever your thing is, and do take regular small actions that make a concrete difference. These might include writing to your MP or a newspaper, making a donation to a progressive cause, or getting involved in your local community. Above all, don’t get sucked into social media spats designed to rob you of your time and energy and peace. Focus on self-care and positive action instead.

I’m doing a lot of what I call ‘respite reading’, because sometimes you really do need to give your head a break. This tends to involve crime novels that contain plenty of wisdom and humour and heart, and I’m incredibly grateful that they exist.

What do you read to get away from it all?

19 thoughts on “A hard rain’s a-gonna fall… Reading as empowerment & solace

  1. Mrs Peabody, please do not assume that all of your readers share the same political views. This is the wrong platform on which to share them.

    • Hello johntxic – I’m not assuming anything of the sort. In our polarized age, it would be highly unlikely for all readers to share the same political views. But this platform — my own blog — is exactly the right space to share my content and views. Fiction, politics and life don’t sit neatly in separate boxes, no matter how much we might wish they did. Best wishes, Mrs P

  2. You are right, this isn’t a normal kind of day. Most of the time I try to ignore what is happening and not get involved in the stories, but today it especially hard.

    I recently read Dark Fire by C.J. Sansom and Tudors by Peter Ackroyd. I learned a lot from both books, but I was also surprised to realize how horrible it was to live at that time and how similar it seemed to be to our current time, in some ways.

    I especially liked your list of series under “respite reading”. Of those series, the only author I have not read is Jørn Lier Horst and it seems I should look into that series.

    Thank you for this post.
    TracyK at Bitter Tea and Mystery

    • Thanks so much, Tracy. You raise a good point about historical fiction sometimes illuminating our own times. I’m always grateful when authors show us those kinds of connections — and there’s some solace knowing that others who came before us have negotiated tricky periods as well.

      I’m glad you liked the respite reading list – another one I like very much is Lesley Thomson’s ‘Detective’s Daughter’ series. Her novels can be hard-hitting at times, but have a wry humour and – again – a lot of heart.

  3. Dear Mrs P,
    Happiest of New Years to you – aside having to watch the USA be ransacked by manbabies. It was so refreshing to see you call it exactly as you see it. I was hoping to ignore it all (Australia is a long way after all) but seeing the co-President issuing Nazi salutes at the dais was horribly disconcerting. They will be worse than we had ever imagined.
    Okay, that’s the vent – thanks so much for the Jean-Claude Izzo tip – we read him while staying a month in Marseille last year. What a joy to walk the streets that he describes so eloquently. We loved Marseille to bits, and are so glad we can revisit again by picking up a book.
    It’s been a terrific year – well last was – for Australian crime-writers – brand new ones. Two tips for you – and anyone reading really:
    GUNNAWAH by Ronni Salt – https://gunnawah.com.au/
    CRAG – by Clare Sutherland – https://versobooks.com.au/p/the-crag

    Cheers!

    • And the Happiest of New Years to you too! Yes, the whole spectacle yesterday was grim — and calls to mind that famous Maya Angelou quote “When someone shows you who they are, believe them”. It’s going to be a very rough ride.

      I’m glad you had the chance to visit Marseille and then to revisit via the Izzo books — their sense of place really is fantastic. And thanks so much for those Australian crime recommendations! I’ll be sure to check them out. There’s lots brilliant crime fiction being written in your part of the world. Here’s to a cracking year of reading x

  4. Thank you Mrs. P, this really helps! During the inauguration yesterday, I thought the best use of my time was to instead watch some old episodes of Columbo instead. I’ve only read Wisting from your ‘respite’ list, so I will explore the rest list in the coming days/years. Thank you for this generous dose of sanity! Thanks again

    • Aw, I’m glad it helped — and I reckon you should win a prize for your Columbo-thon. What an inspired way of making best use of that time!

      I now realise that most of the authors on the respite list are British, which is interesting (I’m possibly retreating to familiar home spaces). The humour is quite British as well, and has an uplifting quality that I like. But none of them are tooooo cosy — they do have some grit and tackle interesting social issues.

      Here’s to generous doses of sanity and solidarity. Warm greetings from across the pond.

  5. Thanks for the always interesting suggestions, and BTW It’s because of a previous post from you that I have now read all the Shardlake books and am now listening to them in audio format…What a grim time that was. I am hoping for peace and sanity to come on earth, eventually.

    • Wow, that’s quite an achievement, as it’s a chunky series and each book is extremely long. I’ve still got some to go myself!

      Is the audio experience bringing out new aspects of the novels? I do love the way they dovetail with the ‘kings and queens’ history we Brits learned at school back in the day, but cast it in a new and much more realistic light.

      Peace and sanity: yes, and it’s surely what the majority of us want…

  6. Haven’t visted your website in years…and I was searching for books

    to take me “out of the news cycle’. I avoided US news for two months (…hard to do as ex-pat) (Nov-Dec)…but I had to watch the Inauguration on 20 January 2025. Just listening to the speech that day made me so upset. I wanted chocolate to soothe me…just a feeling of “emotional eating!” So strange. Now time to settle down for 4 rough years. Your CF suggestions are just what I’ve been looking for. Thanks.

Leave a reply to jmegraw Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.