#19 Maurizio de Giovanni / I Will Have Vengeance

Maurizio de Giovanni, I Will Have Vengeance: The Winter of Commissario Ricciardi, translated from Italian by Anne Milano Appel (Hersilia Press, 2012 [2007]). An intriguing debut novel featuring the mournful Commissario Ricciardi  4 stars

 Opening sentenceThe dead child was standing motionless at the intersection between Santa Teresa and the museum.   

I Will Have Vengeance: The Winter of Commissario Ricciardi was originally published in 2007 and is the first in a series featuring Luigi Alfredo Ricciardi, Commissario of Police with the Regia Questura di Napoli in 1930s Italy. The series has already been translated into French, Spanish and German, and its fourth installment (Il giorno dei morti / The Day of the Dead) won the prestigious Premio Camaiore in 2011.

Given its setting in the Naples of 1931, nine years into Mussolini’s rule, I expected this book to be an interesting but fairly conventional historical crime novel. From the opening line, however, it’s made clear that this text offers readers something different – an investigative figure able to see the dead and hear their last anguished utterances, which (in some cases) can be used to shed light on the manner and cause of their death.

Opting to employ this kind of narrative device is exceedingly risky and difficult to pull off. However, de Giovanni selects just the right style and tone to allow the reader to suspend disbelief, one that I found a little reminiscent of magical realist authors such as Isabel Allende:

“He saw the dead. Not all of them, and not for long: only those who had died violently, and only for a period of time that revealed extreme emotion, the sudden energy of their final thoughts. He saw them as though in a photograph that captured the moment their lives ended, one whose contours slowly faded until they disappeared” (p. 12).

Ricciardi’s daily exposure to the turbulent emotions of the dead leaves him an introverted, isolated and damaged individual, who is watched over by devoted family servant Rosa at home and by Brigadier Raffaele Maione at work. The original title of the novel, il senso del dolore (which can be translated as ‘a sense of sorrow’ / ‘a sense of pain’), could apply equally to the sorrow radiating from the departed and to its effect on Ricciardi. His is an interesting, nuanced character, imbued with an appealing stoicism when handling a ‘life sentence’ (p. 12) of receiving messages from the restless dead.

So can I Will Have Vengeance also be viewed as a historical crime novel? In many respects, yes. Mussolini’s fascist regime is mentioned very early on, and the social framework within which Ricciardi has to operate is visible throughout the text. For example, Ricciardi is shown musing on the regime’s attitude to crime, which supposedly does not exist within ordered fascist society: ‘No crime, only safety and well-being dictated by the regime. So it was ordained, by decree. Yet the dead kept vigil in the streets, in homes, demanding peace and justice’ (p.99). He is also shown having to manage a demanding superior, Vice Questore Garzo, who is loyal to the regime, albeit for personal gain rather than due to ideological conviction.

However, unlike other crime novels featuring investigators working within repressive regimes, such as Philip Kerr’s Bernie Gunther (Nazi Germany), Tim Robb Smith’s Leo Demidov and William Ryan’s Alexei Korolev (Stalin’s Russia), there is no sustained examination of the moral difficulties encountered by a policeman working in the service of the state and of the political dangers he might face. Ricciardi appears to be largely apolitical, is shielded by his record as an outstanding investigator, and does things ‘his way’ with relative ease when investigating the murder of renowned tenor Maestro Vezzi (a wonderfully drawn character, whose case will delight opera buffs). It will be interesting to see if this portrayal of Ricciardi remains the same in subsequent books within the series, or whether he is shown becoming embroiled in sticky political situations further down the line.

In sum: this is a very enjoyable read, which expertly fuses elements of the historical crime novel with a distinctive, other-worldly dimension, courtesy of its police investigator’s highly unusual abilities. I look forward to reading the other novels in the series soon.

The first chapter of the novel is available on the Hersilia Press website.

With thanks to Hersilia Press for providing me with a proof copy to review.

Mrs Peabody awards I Will Have Vengeance an entertaining, ghostly 4 stars.

Creative Commons License

10 thoughts on “#19 Maurizio de Giovanni / I Will Have Vengeance

  1. Thanks for the review Mrs P – I have yet to sample this author, The magic realist element did have me worried about as it is, as you so rightly point out, really hard to do. Very much looking forward to tracking this one down – consider me completely persuaded!



    • Thanks very much, Sergio. I hope you enjoy it as much as I did. It has a very different feel to other Italian crime I’ve read so far and is clearly trying something rather unusual. As I said, I’ll be very interested to see in which direction the central character is taken in the other books, and how far the personal, professional and political are made to intersect. Definitely a series I’ll be following up! Best, Mrs P.

  2. I have been tempted to read this book, although not a great fan of magical realism. Also, I don’t know how someone can work in the employ of a fascist state without carrying out their program of repression and brutality. This is an enigma to me. It seems as it a police officer would have to accede and do what’s required or subtly undermine the regime or do it more overtly, thus risking job and even more. To straddle the fence would seem to be an impossible task. But it’s interesting nevertheless.

    • Thanks for your comment, Kathy. Yes, absolutely, I take your point. The fascist context isn’t ignored in the book by any means, but isn’t as central as it could have been (possibly because much of this opening novel in the series is explaining R’s very unusual abilities). But it might seem strange in future books if R’s political position were not probed more deeply. Will be interesting to see where it goes.

      There’s some analysis of class / power dynamics in the novel as well – so the author is certainly interested in social issues.

  3. Excellent review. I could appreciate that this is a good novel, but it wasn’t quite my cup of tea – the supernatural elements were fine for me as they were sensitively written and did not intrude on the narrative. But I don’t read much historical or Agatha Christie-style fiction so this book didn’t tick the boxes for me. I do think it is well written and will please many readers. I quite liked the understated approach to the fascist context – maybe that will come more to the fore in the other books in the series?

    • Many thanks, Maxine. Yes, I thought it was well written too, and credit should also go to the translator, Anne Milano Appel, for doing such a great job.

      I can see that the novel may not appeal to all (either because they are not keen on the magical realist element or alternatively, are not drawn to historical crime) – but I thought it was a really interesting attempt to do something a little different in terms of the genre. I’m not quite sure how to categorise it (if indeed one must) – ‘off-beat historical crime fiction’ is the best I can come up with at the moment!

  4. Pingback: Review: I Will Have Vengeance by Maurizio de Giovanni | The Game's Afoot

  5. Pingback: The Crime Writers’ Association Awards 2012 | Mrs. Peabody Investigates

Please leave your comment here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.