#1 Indridason/The Draining Lake

Arnaldur Indriđason, The Draining Lake (London: Harvill Secker, 2007 [2004]). Wrap up warm for a chilly Icelandic police procedural. 5 stars

Although this 2004 novel is written by an Icelander and set in Reykjavik, it’s firmly indebted to the classic Swedish police procedural. Detective Inspector Erlendur Sveinsson can be viewed as a third-generation representative of the Swedish police investigator, following in the footsteps of Sjöwall and Wahlöö’s Martin Beck, and Henning Mankell’s Kurt Wallander. Morose, cynical and consumed with self-doubt, these policemen have become progressively more embattled and isolated with each generation. In Erlendur’s case, he’s forced to question the extent to which his absence as a father is responsible for his daughter’s slide into a drug addiction – one the novel describes in sober and hard-hitting detail.

The draining lake of the title is Lake Kleifarvatn, whose mysteriously receding waters reveal an old skeleton weighed down with a heavy Russian radio device. As Erlendur and his team begin the painstaking process of investigating this strange find, they are transported back to an era of international espionage and political unrest during the Cold War, whose consequences can only now be fully understood.

Two things lift this crime novel a cut above the average police procedural. The first is the fascinating insight the novel gives into the Cold War period, and in particular, the experiences of young, idealistic, Icelandic communists who were offered the opportunity to study in East Germany in the 1950s. The second is the sensitive treatment of the theme of ‘the missing’ and of the impact that losing someone without knowing his or her final fate can have on the individual.

A number of the characters, including Erlendur, have lost someone close to them, and the novel is haunted by their many absences. While some eventually learn what happened to their loved ones, others are not so fortunate. They, and crucially the reader, are left without an adequate resolution to the story of these disappearances, a deliberate omission that adds tremendous power to the narrative. Thus, while the central murder is solved, other aspects of the plot are left open, questioning the notion that a case can ever be fully solved. We might know who the murderer is, and understand what motivated them, but the void left by ‘the missing’ remains.

The Draining Lake is well written, enjoyable and thought-provoking: a first-rate, multi-layered crime novel. Erlendur is a welcome and worthy successor to Beck and Wallander, and the novel’s Icelandic setting adds a beguiling and unusual dimension to the chilly subgenre of dark, Nordic crime.

The novel is the 4th in the ‘Reykjavik murder mystery series’, and in my view, it’s the best so far.

Mrs. Peabody awards The Draining Lake a mighty 5 stars

9 thoughts on “#1 Indridason/The Draining Lake

  1. Pingback: JAR CITY by Arnaldur Indridason | Tipping My Fedora

  2. Pingback: SILENCE OF THE GRAVE (2002) by Arnaldur Indriðason | Tipping My Fedora

  3. Pingback: Top 5 – Nordic Crime | Mrs. Peabody Investigates

  4. Great review. I think this is my favourite in this excellent series. I think Erlunder is even more depressed than Beck or Wallander – I see him that way anyway. I realise it’s a thin distinction! I agree with you that the cold war/Leipzig aspects were very moving in this book, and hence gave it more emotional resonance han some of the others in this series. Another aspect of it that I really loved is the humour, mainly directed against the Americans as Erlunder & colleague (forget which) go round the embassies.

    • Thanks, Maxine, for taking the time to browse and comment on my first ever review! The Draining Lake is my favourite too, though I haven’t read all of the series, and yes, I’d agree that Erlunder is the bleakest of the three investigative figures (and who can blame him given his highly troubled kids) – not quite sure where there is to go after this one in that respect! You’re right about the humour too: important not to forget this aspect of Nordic noir.

  5. Pingback: Review: The Draining Lake, by Arnaldur Indridason | The Game's Afoot

  6. Pingback: Arnaldur Indriðason’s Strange Shores / Iceland Noir | Mrs. Peabody Investigates

  7. Pingback: American, Icelandic and Swedish gems: Paretsky, Indriđason and Nesser | Mrs. Peabody Investigates

  8. Pingback: Eva Dolan’s After You Die (UK), Val McDermid’s Out of Bounds (UK) and Iceland Noir 2016 | Mrs. Peabody Investigates

Comments are closed.